Published: 2016-12-15

A comparative study of feto-maternal outcome in instrumental vaginal delivery at tertiary health level hospital in Uttarakhand state

Priyanka Chaudhari, Neeta Bansal, Vineeta Gupta, Archna Tandon, Anjali Chaudhry


Background: Instrumental vaginal delivery is an age-long obstetric practice used to expedite vaginal delivery or avert recourse to caesarean delivery. Objective of the study is to compare maternal and neonatal outcomes of vacuum and forceps application in instrumental vaginal delivery.

Methods: This is a retrospective observational study. Retrospective study of 70 consecutive ventouse and 70 consecutive forceps deliveries was done. Maternal and neonatal morbidity were compared in terms of perineal laceration, episiotomy extension, postpartum hemorrhage, apgar score, neonatal injuries and NICU admissions.

Results: Maternal morbidity in terms of periurethral tear, second and third degree perineal tear were significantly more in forceps group (p=0.0332 and p=0.0173 respectively). However neonatal outcomes were found to be similar in both types of instrumental deliveries.

Conclusions: Ventouse should be preferred over forceps whenever there is an indication for instrumental delivery (except in fetal distress) as it is associated with less maternal trauma and most of the neonatal morbidities were insignificant in comparison with both instruments.


Instrumental delivery, Forceps, Vacuum extraction, Maternal morbidity, Perinatal outcomes

Full Text:



Anonymous. Vacuum versus forceps. (Editorial). Lancet. 1984;1:144.

Meniru GI. An analysis of recent trends in vacuum extraction and forceps delivery in the United Kingdom. BJOG: An Intern J Obstetr Gynaecol. 1996;103(2):168-70.

Learman LA. Regional differences in operative obstetrics: a look to the South. Obstetrics & Gynecology. 1998;92(4 Part 1):514-9.

Hillier CE, Johanson RB. Worldwide survey of assisted vaginal delivery. Intern J Gynecol Obstetr. 1994;47(2):109-14.

Johanson RB, Rice C, Doyle M, Arthur J, Anyanwu L, Ibrahim J, et al. A randomised prospective study comparing the new vacuum extractor policy with forceps delivery. Intern J Obstetr Gynaecol. 1993;100(6):524-30.

Caughey AB, Sandberg PL, Zlatnik MG, Thiet MP, Parer JT, Laros Jr RK. Forceps compared with vacuum: rates of neonatal and maternal morbidity. Obstetr Gynecol. 2006;107(3):740.

Bofill JA, Rust OA, Schorr SJ, Brown RC, Martin RW, Martin JN, et al. A randomized prospective trial of the obstetric forceps versus the M-cup vacuum extractor. Am J Obstetr Gynecol. 1996;175(5):1325-30.

Johnson JH, Figueroa R, Garry D, Elimian A, Maulik D. Immediate maternal and neonatal effects of forceps and vacuum-assisted deliveries. Obstetr Gynecol. 2004;103(3):513-8.

Vacca A, Grant A, Wyatt G, Chalmers I. Portsmouth operative delivery trial: a comparison vacuum extraction and forceps delivery. Intern J Obstetr Gynaecol. 1983;90(12):1107-12.

Towner D, Castro MA, Eby-Wilkens E, Gilbert WM. Effect of mode of delivery in nulliparous women on neonatal intracranial injury. New England journal of medicine. 1999;341(23):1709-14.

Wen SW, Liu S, Kramer MS, Marcoux S, Ohlsson A, Sauvé R, et al. Comparison of maternal and infant outcomes between vacuum extraction and forceps deliveries. American journal of epidemiology. 2001;153(2):103-7.

Pam IC, Otubu JA. Instrumental delivery. In: Agboola A, editor. Textbook of Obstetrics and Gynaecology for Medical Students. 2nd ed. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books Nig. Plc; 2006:489-494.

Hook CD, Damos JR. Vacuum-assisted vaginal delivery. Am Family Physician. 2008;78(8): 953-60.

Lawani LO, Anozie OB, Ezeonu PO, Iyoke CA. Comparison of outcomes between operative vaginal deliveries and spontaneous vaginal deliveries in southeast Nigeria. Intern J Gynecol Obstetr. 2014;125(3):206-9.

Arias F, Daftary SN, Bhide AG. Abnormal labour and delivery. Operative vaginal delivery. IN:Arias F, Daftary SN, Bhide AG, eds. Practical guide to high risk pregnancy and delivery,a south-asian perspective. 3rd ed. India: Elsievier Health Sciences; 2008:86-396.

Chalmers I, Enkin M, Keirse MJ. Effective care in pregnancy and childbirth: Pregnancy. Oxford University Press, USA; 1989.

Okunwobi‐Smith Y, Cooke I, MacKenzie IZ. Decision to delivery intervals for assisted vaginal vertex delivery. Intern J Obstetr Gynaecol. 2000;107(4):467-71.

Lurie S, Glezerman M, Sadan O. Maternal and neonatal effects of forceps versus vacuum operative vaginal delivery. Intern J Gynecol Obstetr. 2005;89(3):293-4.

Akhtar S. Comparison of maternal and infant outcome between vacuum extraction and forceps deliveries. Pakistan Armed Force Med J. 2006;2(1):25-31.

Nkwabong E, Nana PN, Mbu R, Takang W, Ekono MR, Kouam L. Indications and maternofetal outcome of instrumental deliveries at the University Teaching Hospital of Yaounde, Cameroon. Tropical doctor. 2011;41(1):5-7.

Singh A, Rathore P. A comparative study of feto-maternal outcome in instrumental vaginal delivery. The Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology of India. 2011;61(6):663-6.

Achanna S, Monga D. Outcome of forceps delivery versus vacuum extraction-a review of 200 cases. Parity. 1994;3(1.4):3-4.

Johanson RB, Menon BK. Vacuum extraction versus forceps for assisted vaginal delivery. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2000;2:CD000224.

Eason E, Labrecque M, Marcoux S, Mondor M.. Anal incontinence after childbirth. CMAJ: Canadian Med Assoc J. 2002;166(3):326-30.

Johanson R, Menon V. Soft versus rigid vacuum extractor cups for assisted vaginal delivery. The Cochrane Library. 2000.

Demissie K, Rhoads GG, Smulian JC, Balasubramanian BA, Gandhi K, Joseph KS, et al. Operative vaginal delivery and neonatal and infant adverse outcomes: population based retrospective analysis. BMJ. 2004;329(7456):24.

Gardella C, Taylor M, Benedetti T, Hitti J, Critchlow C. The effect of sequential use of vacuum and forceps for assisted vaginal delivery on neonatal and maternal outcomes. Am Journal of Obstetr Gynecol. 2001;185(4):896-902.

Lamba A, Kaur R, Muzafar Z. An observational study to evaluate the maternal and neonatal outcome of forceps delivery in a tertiary care government hospital of a cosmopolitan city of India. Age (years). 2016;20(17):24.

Prameela RC, Prajwal S. Assisted vaginal delivery, Forceps, Ventouse. Outcome of instrumental vaginal deliveries in referred cases. Journal of evolution of medical and dental sciences 2015;4(19):3275-80.